Culture War in WOMEN TALKING

 

Based on a true story, Women Talking is an allegorical tale of abuse brought to emotional angst by writer/director Sarah Polley and a great cast.

In a remote, Mennonite settlement where the way of life is devoid of modern technology and conveniences, girls are repeatedly victims of sexual assault by the village men amid a culture of male domination where only the boys receive schooling and grow up to perpetuate this vicious cycle of violence.  With no prospect of change, many of the women (including Rooney Mara, Claire Foy, Jessie Buckley, and Frances McDormand), who suffer from anxiety, anger, and depression, band together to discuss their options. In their world where ‘what they think does not matter’, and knowing any dissent could result in being banished from the settlement, their desperation gives way to a courageous plan.  Can they find a way out of their hopelessness and forge a better life for themselves and their children?

This is a great ensemble of actresses (while Ben Whishaw has a significant role as a trustworthy male), and though the film almost feels like a stage production primarily set in a barn, Polley makes this a cinematic journey with effective use of cinematography, music and editing. What is remarkable is how simple lines of dialogue coalesce into unexpectedly powerful moments, and you will have an appreciation for these brave women who risk everything. The film explores each woman’s personal reasons to leave or stay while guided by specific tenets including- to protect their children (especially the girls), being true to their religious faith, and having the right to free thinking.

It’s a minimalist story, but by the end, the emotional payoff is affecting and resonates, (potentially triggering a trauma response for the audience).  It’s an important film with far-reaching implications for humanity. 

  **** of **** stars